** Denotes CAP Mainstage debut
| Role | Actor |
| Curly McLain | Isaiah Wing |
| Aunt Eller | Tatum Murphy |
| Laurey Williams | Paige Gossard** |
| Ike | Ian McGovern |
| Fred | Grant Guiter** |
| Will Parker | Ethan Smith |
| Jud Fry | William Brown |
| Ado Annie | Claire Hintz |
| Ali Hakim, the Peddler | Nick Meredith |
| Gertie Cummings | Marianna Hintz |
| June | Georgia Ballard** |
| Ellen | Natalie Aanonson |
| Kate | Cadence Spurgeon |
| Virginia | Addisyn Marvin |
| Vivian | Eve Wing |
| Andrew Carnes | August Nau |
| Cord Elam | Nolan Haacke** |
| Slim | Austin Summers |
| Mike | Ethan Quinn |
| Joe | Emmitt Reyerson** |
| Ensemble | Peyton Haacke** |
| Ensemble | Hazel Engelbrecht** |
| Ensemble | Lia Hintz |
| Ensemble | Kathryn Nau |
| Ensemble | Ellie Smith** |