** = denotes CAP mainstage debut
| Role | Actor |
|---|---|
| Peter Pan | Aurora Grooters |
| Wendy Darling | Grace Corwin |
| John Darling | Aidan Farrell |
| Michael Darling | Aron Somers ** |
| Nibs (Lost Boy) | Isaiah Wing |
| Slightly (Lost Boy) | Evan Marshall |
| Curley (Lost Boy) | Hank Jones |
| Twin #1 (Lost Boy) | Joey Lopez ** |
| Twin #2 (Lost Boy) | Charlie Downing |
| Tootles (Lost Boy) | Owen Nicolino |
| Lost Boy ensemble | Karissa Lyons |
| Lost Boy ensemble | Allison Halstead |
| Captain Hook / Mr Darling | Price Jacobsen |
| Smee / Mrs Darling | Chloe Williams |
| Noodler (Pirate) | August Nau |
| Jukes (Pirate) | Griffin Sutten |
| Starkey (Pirate) | Nick Meredith |
| Cecco (Pirate) | Carson Campbell |
| Pirate Ensemble | Cadence Spurgeon ** |
| Pirate Ensemble | Sydney Pride |
| Tiger Lily (Brave Girl) | Eve Wing ** |
| Small Brave Girl | Vivian Rosalie Coleman ** |
| Brave Girl #1 | Grace Harvey ** |
| Brave Girl #2 | Nora Somers |
| Brave Girl ensemble | Khloe Grasmick ** |
| Brave Girl ensemble | Eryn Lenhart |
| Brave Girl ensemble | Alison Keeler |
| Brave Girl ensemble | Hannah Siefken ** |
** = denotes CAP mainstage debut